A High-Profile Murder Case Reverberates in Western Cape High Court - Cape Town Today
Customize Consent Preferences

We use cookies to help you navigate efficiently and perform certain functions. You will find detailed information about all cookies under each consent category below.

The cookies that are categorized as "Necessary" are stored on your browser as they are essential for enabling the basic functionalities of the site. ... 

Always Active

Necessary cookies are required to enable the basic features of this site, such as providing secure log-in or adjusting your consent preferences. These cookies do not store any personally identifiable data.

No cookies to display.

Functional cookies help perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collecting feedback, and other third-party features.

No cookies to display.

Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics such as the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.

No cookies to display.

Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.

No cookies to display.

Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with customized advertisements based on the pages you visited previously and to analyze the effectiveness of the ad campaigns.

No cookies to display.

A High-Profile Murder Case Reverberates in Western Cape High Court

4 mins read
south africa western cape high court

The trial for the assassination of Lieutenant Colonel Charl Kinnear began on Monday in the Western Cape Division of the High Court. 14 individuals, including reputed organized crime mastermind Nafiz Modack, are facing charges related to the killing. The outcome of the trial will have larger implications for Cape Town’s ongoing struggle against organized crime. The trial signifies a reckoning with the forces that infringe on the city’s heart, and its outcome will send a clear message to those who dare cross the thin blue line.

What is the trial for Lieutenant Colonel Charl Kinnear’s assassination?

14 individuals, including reputed organized crime mastermind Nafiz Modack, are facing charges related to the assassination of Lieutenant Colonel Charl Kinnear outside his residence in Bishop Lavis during 2020. The trial commenced on Monday in the Western Cape Division of the High Court, with 124 criminal charges listed on the docket. The outcome of the trial will have larger implications for Cape Town’s ongoing struggle against organized crime.

The Trial Begins

On Monday, the stately corridors of Western Cape Division of the High Court resonated with the seriousness of an important case—an investigation into Lieutenant Colonel Charl Kinnear’s assassination commenced. A loyal member of the Anti-Gang Unit, Kinnear encountered a cruel fate outside his residence in Bishop Lavis during 2020. Currently, 14 individuals are facing charges related to his ruthless killing, each under the meticulous scrutiny of the court and an anticipating nation.

Prominently featured among the accused is Nafiz Modack, reputedly a mastermind of organized crime. His fellow defendants encompass the likes of Zane Kilian and, in a more shocking revelation, Ashley Tabisher, a former compatriot of Kinnear in the Anti-Gang Unit. Neither Modack nor Kilian were accompanied by legal counsel, an unsettling show of audacity or a stark reflection of the severity of the accusations they’re grappling with.

The Circumstances Surrounding Kinnear’s Death

Kinnear’s untimely departure followed a sudden revocation of his security team, a detail that sends shivers down the spine given his active involvement in probing organized crime syndicates and fellow officers suspected of procuring illegal firearm licenses for criminals. Among those under Kinnear’s investigative lens was none other than Modack himself.

In the wake of Kinnear’s demise, his family has found themselves cocooned under the protection of the South African Police Service (SAPS). However, in an ironic twist, his widow Nicolette recently disclosed that her SAPS-provided security cover was to be revoked just before the murder trial began. As predicted, the security mechanism was indeed discontinued a day prior to the trial’s commencement.

The Court Proceedings

The gravity of Monday’s courtroom proceedings was palpable, underscored by an astounding 124 criminal charges listed on the docket. The indictment against the group accuses them of engaging in ‘illegal activities of an enterprise from December 2017 until January 2021’. Those who submitted pleas adamantly professed their innocence, denying any associations with the criminal organization purportedly linked to Modack.

Apart from the charges related to Kinnear’s murder, Modack also had to confront charges pertaining to an unrelated 2017 homicide outside a venue in Cape Town. In midst of these mounting accusations, Modack lodged a request for a relocation from Helderstroom Correctional Centre to a prison nearer to the court, alongside a curious request for a light fixture in his cell to facilitate his reading of the indictment. Judge Robert Henney suggested that correctional services staff should consider these requests.

The Larger Implications

As the trial proceeds, the Western Cape Division of the High Court emerges as a battlefield of justice, wrestling with a tangled nexus of accusations, treacheries, and deceit. The case concerning Lieutenant Colonel Charl Kinnear’s assassination casts an ominous shadow over Cape Town, a metropolis ensnared in a relentless struggle against organized crime.

This trial signifies more than a mere pursuit of justice; it embodies a face-off with the city’s darker elements, a reckoning with the forces that infringe on its very heart. The case’s outcome will undoubtedly reverberate throughout the city, sending a clear message to those who dare cross the thin blue line and reminding citizens of the enduring struggle against crime that law enforcement officials face daily.

How many individuals are facing charges related to the assassination of Lieutenant Colonel Charl Kinnear?

14 individuals, including reputed organized crime mastermind Nafiz Modack, are facing charges related to the assassination of Lieutenant Colonel Charl Kinnear outside his residence in Bishop Lavis during 2020.

What is the significance of the trial for Cape Town’s ongoing struggle against organized crime?

The outcome of the trial will have larger implications for Cape Town’s ongoing struggle against organized crime. The trial signifies a reckoning with the forces that infringe on the city’s heart, and its outcome will send a clear message to those who dare cross the thin blue line.

What were the circumstances surrounding Kinnear’s death?

Kinnear’s untimely departure followed a sudden revocation of his security team, a detail that sends shivers down the spine given his active involvement in probing organized crime syndicates and fellow officers suspected of procuring illegal firearm licenses for criminals.

What were some of the charges listed on the docket for the trial?

The indictment against the group accuses them of engaging in ‘illegal activities of an enterprise from December 2017 until January 2021’. Those who submitted pleas adamantly professed their innocence, denying any associations with the criminal organization purportedly linked to Modack.

What are the larger implications of the trial?

This trial signifies more than a mere pursuit of justice; it embodies a face-off with the city’s darker elements, a reckoning with the forces that infringe on its very heart. The case’s outcome will undoubtedly reverberate throughout the city, sending a clear message to those who dare cross the thin blue line and reminding citizens of the enduring struggle against crime that law enforcement officials face daily.

Who is Nafiz Modack?

Nafiz Modack is a reputed organized crime mastermind who is prominently featured among the accused in the trial for the assassination of Lieutenant Colonel Charl Kinnear. Apart from the charges related to Kinnear’s murder, Modack also had to confront charges pertaining to an unrelated 2017 homicide outside a venue in Cape Town.

Previous Story

A Pivotal Judgment: Upholding Decorum and Rule of Law in South Africa

Next Story

Football Star Thamsanqa Gabuza’s Unfolding Legal Drama: A Struggle for an Orlando Pirates Legend

Latest from Blog

Cape Town on the Horizon: South Africa’s Thrilling Cruise Season 2025–2026

Cape Town’s 2025–2026 cruise season promises exciting adventures on stylish ships like Sirena and Crystal Symphony. Travelers can enjoy fun themed cruises full of music, art, and local culture while exploring the stunning coastline with Table Mountain as a backdrop. The city’s lively waterfront buzzes with events, markets, and warm welcomes, making every cruise arrival feel like a grand celebration. With easy travel packages and ecofriendly ships, this season offers a perfect blend of luxury, discovery, and relaxation by the sea.

The Gathering Storms: Winter’s Challenge Approaches the Cape

The Cape is bracing for two strong winter storms bringing heavy rain, fierce winds up to 75 km/h, flooding, and even snow in the mountains. The wild weather will challenge roads, farms, and coastal communities, as people prepare to protect homes, livestock, and boats. Despite the danger, there’s a deep respect and shared spirit among locals who have weathered such storms for generations. These fierce cold fronts remind everyone of nature’s power and the strength of community in tough times.

South Africa’s Budget Tightrope: Tax Strategies, Fuel Levies, and the Cost of Policy Choices

South Africa’s budget faces tough challenges like high debt and slow growth, forcing the government to find smart ways to raise money without upsetting people too much. Instead of raising VAT, it leans on higher taxes on alcohol, tobacco, and fuel to bring in cash. These moves help fill the budget gap but also make life harder for many ordinary South Africans, who feel the pinch in daily costs. The government also uses “bracket creep,” quietly taxing more as incomes rise with inflation. Balancing the budget while keeping the country stable and fair is a delicate and ongoing struggle.

Reinventing Runway: How a Montagu Dress Redefined Sustainable Style in the Cape

A Montagu dress made from recycled plastic bags stunned the Cape’s runway, turning trash into a shining symbol of style and sustainability. Created by a creative mother and worn by a young model, the gown showed how everyday waste can become beautiful fashion with heart and purpose. This powerful dress sparked cheers and hope, proving that caring for the planet and looking amazing can go hand in hand. It was a bold reminder that with creativity and community, we can rethink waste and build a brighter, greener future.

Mossel Bay Set to Shine: UIPM Biathle, Triathle, and Laser Run World Championships 2025

In December 2025, Mossel Bay in South Africa will light up the world stage by hosting the UIPM Biathle, Triathle, and Laser Run World Championships. This exciting event features fast swimming, running, and laser shooting, bringing athletes from all over the globe together in a celebration of sport and culture. Families and competitors of all ages will share the thrill, showing how the sport welcomes everyone. Set against the beautiful Santos Beach, the championships promise unforgettable races, new friendships, and a bright future for African sport.