Butterworth Residents Voice Concerns over Tobacco Control Bill - Cape Town Today
Customize Consent Preferences

We use cookies to help you navigate efficiently and perform certain functions. You will find detailed information about all cookies under each consent category below.

The cookies that are categorized as "Necessary" are stored on your browser as they are essential for enabling the basic functionalities of the site. ... 

Always Active

Necessary cookies are required to enable the basic features of this site, such as providing secure log-in or adjusting your consent preferences. These cookies do not store any personally identifiable data.

No cookies to display.

Functional cookies help perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collecting feedback, and other third-party features.

No cookies to display.

Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics such as the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.

No cookies to display.

Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.

No cookies to display.

Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with customized advertisements based on the pages you visited previously and to analyze the effectiveness of the ad campaigns.

No cookies to display.

Butterworth Residents Voice Concerns over Tobacco Control Bill

2 mins read
Media Statement: Butterworth Residents Call for Attention on Reduction of Unemployment and Loadshedding than on Regulating Tobacco Products

Public Hearing on B33-2022

Amidst the bustling activities in the heart of the Amatole District Municipality, Butterworth’s inhabitants have expressed their concerns. Bearing the burden of a high unemployment rate and recurrent loadshedding, they insist that these matters should headline the Parliamentary agenda instead of the regulation of tobacco products.

The debate about this surfaced during the first of three public hearings on the Tobacco Products and Electronic Delivery Systems Control Bill (B33-2022). The hearing took place at the Butterworth Town Hall. The Bill intends to bolster public health protective procedures, revamp the South African tobacco control law to meet the World Health Organization Framework Convention’s standards, and invalidate the 1993 Tobacco Control Act. This proposed legislation sparked a range of responses from the townsfolk.

A Mixed Reaction from the Public

The townspeople’s opinions varied widely, with some forcefully endorsing the Bill and others strongly rebutting it. The most controversial point of contention revolves around the Bill’s potential effect on unemployment. The Bill’s critics express their fears that its execution might exacerbate the already high unemployment rates within the tobacco industry and along the entire tobacco value chain. Additionally, they are anxious about potential fiscal repercussions if revenue from tobacco sales decreases, possibly impacting necessary social programs’ provision.

However, the Bill’s proponents counter these arguments, stressing that small-scale traders should refocus their efforts on less damaging products. They assert that the regulation of tobacco products will bring about a greater societal benefit by controlling the rising consumption among young South Africans. They criticize the current advertising guidelines for luring the youth into smoking and believe that enforcing this Bill and banning advertising at points of purchase will lead to decreased consumption.

Technical Criticisms and Concerns for Small-Scale Traders

The Bill also faced technical criticisms. Some townsfolk disagreed with the Bill’s preamble that categorizes nicotine as a detrimental substance. They argue that nicotine, while addictive, isn’t directly toxic or cancer-causing. They believe this distinction is imperative to encourage the use of harm reduction products.

The plight of small-scale traders was also highlighted. These traders expressed their disapproval of the Bill, arguing that its enforcement could threaten their businesses’ survival, disempowering them and possibly hindering their ability to provide for their families. They also expressed worry that the Bill could lead to heightened scrutiny from law enforcement agencies and potentially promote the sale of illegal cigarettes in the market.

The Bill’s supporters, on the other hand, praised its merits. They applauded the intensified ban on selling tobacco products to young children but acknowledged the need to strengthen monitoring mechanisms to ensure regulatory compliance. They expressed strong support for the ban on selling tobacco products through vending machines, which would restrict access by young children.

The Democratic Process in Action

Despite divergent views, the hearing was characterized by a genuine spirit of public participation. The committee’s chairperson, Dr. Kenneth Jacobs, expressed appreciation for the diverse inputs and assured everyone that each would receive thorough consideration. “This is democracy in action,” he stated, “and we are confident that the hearings met the standard of meaningful public participation.”

Potential Changes and Continuing Debates

If enacted, the Bill will instigate broad changes, including designating indoor public spaces and specific outdoor areas as completely smoke-free zones, prohibiting cigarette sales through vending machines, mandatory plain packaging with graphic health warnings and pictorials, a ban on displaying products at points of sale, and regulating electronic nicotine and non-nicotine delivery systems.

The unexpected relocation of the Queenstown public hearings was deemed necessary to create an environment conducive to effective public participation. Dr. Jacobs stressed measures have been implemented to prevent any disadvantage to the participants due to the change in location.

As the debate rages on, the public hearings continue, offering a platform for the residents to express their worries, aspirations, and fears. Through these dialogues, they are not only influencing the future of tobacco control in South Africa but also drawing attention to the pressing issues of unemployment and loadshedding that affect their everyday lives, embodying the very spirit of democracy.

Previous Story

South African Rugby Coach Rassie Erasmus Rushed to Hospital

Next Story

Public Participation in Gauteng Province Influences General Intelligence Laws Amendment Bill

Latest from Blog

The Untamed Beauty of South Africa’s West Coast

South Africa’s West Coast is a breathtaking mix of golden sands and the cool Atlantic waves, perfect for nature lovers. Here, you can find amazing campsites like Silwerstroomstrand Resort, great for families, and Ganzekraal Coastal Resort, where adventure meets relaxation. Yzerfontein Caravan Park offers a cozy spot near untouched beaches, while Tietiesbaai invites you to reconnect with nature in a rustic setting. Don’t miss Groenrivier Coastal Campsites, especially when the wildflowers bloom, painting the landscape in vibrant colors. Each site promises a unique escape into the wild beauty of the coast!

Navigating the Depths of Climate Change: Insights from the SA Agulhas II

The SA Agulhas II is a crucial ship for studying climate change, sailing from Antarctica to Africa to collect important information about the ocean and its ecosystems. This floating laboratory helps scientists understand how rising ocean temperatures affect weather patterns and coastal communities in South Africa. Its research highlights the urgent need to protect our planet, showing that the ocean’s health is key to our survival. As it prepares for its next journey, the SA Agulhas II remains a symbol of hope and knowledge in the fight against climate change.

Revitalizing Muizenberg Beach: Preserving History While Embracing Change

Muizenberg Beach is getting a fresh makeover while keeping its historic charm intact! The City of Cape Town plans to replace the iconic beach huts with new replicas that look just like the originals, preserving the colorful spirit of this beloved spot. As the beach evolves to face challenges like rising sea levels, the community will have a chance to share their thoughts and hopes in upcoming meetings. This exciting project blends the past with the future, ensuring that Muizenberg remains a special place for everyone to enjoy.

Elon Musk’s Cape Town Commentary: A Catalyst for Conversation

Elon Musk recently called Cape Town a “beautiful theme park,” highlighting its appeal and safety for tourists. His comments sparked a lively conversation about the city’s charm and the importance of safety for visitors. In response, Cape Town’s mayor, Geordin HillLewis, proudly showcased the city’s beauty and vibrant community, inviting Musk to experience it firsthand. He also shared plans to boost safety and encourage tourism as key to the local economy, painting a picture of Cape Town as a lively and resilient place, full of culture and heart.

Amazeballs: Pioneering Sustainability in Sports Equipment

Amazeballs is a bright star in the world of sports and sustainability! This amazing nonprofit takes old padel and tennis balls and turns them into cool things like furniture and playground surfaces. By reusing these balls, Amazeballs helps keep tons of waste out of landfills and shows everyone how creative design can protect our planet. With the help of talented South African designers, they create stylish pieces that are not only fun but also good for the Earth. Amazeballs is inspiring people to rethink waste and embrace a greener future!