Engaging the Community in the Debate: The Tobacco Products and Electronic Delivery Systems Control Bill - Cape Town Today
Customize Consent Preferences

We use cookies to help you navigate efficiently and perform certain functions. You will find detailed information about all cookies under each consent category below.

The cookies that are categorized as "Necessary" are stored on your browser as they are essential for enabling the basic functionalities of the site. ... 

Always Active

Necessary cookies are required to enable the basic features of this site, such as providing secure log-in or adjusting your consent preferences. These cookies do not store any personally identifiable data.

No cookies to display.

Functional cookies help perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collecting feedback, and other third-party features.

No cookies to display.

Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics such as the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.

No cookies to display.

Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.

No cookies to display.

Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with customized advertisements based on the pages you visited previously and to analyze the effectiveness of the ad campaigns.

No cookies to display.

Engaging the Community in the Debate: The Tobacco Products and Electronic Delivery Systems Control Bill

2 mins read
Media Statement: Queenstown Residents Call for Differentiated Regulations between Tobacco and Electronic Delivery Systems

As the first light of dawn painted the Ashley Wyngaardt Community Hall in Queenstown, Eastern Cape, a vigorous discussion was taking place. Inhabitants of the Chris Hani District Municipality were passionately exchanging opinions about the Tobacco Products and Electronic Delivery Systems Control Bill (B33-2022). This was the second in a series of three public hearings conducted in the Eastern Cape. The central request from the participants was for a nuanced approach to the regulation of tobacco products and electronic delivery systems.

A Community That Fights For Its Beliefs

The Chris Hani District Municipality, named after the respected South African anti-apartheid activist, is home to residents who aren’t afraid to advocate for their convictions. Reflecting the spirit of their namesake, they argued fervently and passionately. The primary focus of their argument? They perceive electronic delivery systems as less harmful than traditional cigarettes and view them as potential aids in the mission to reduce tobacco usage.

However, their arguments were not based on perceptions alone. They also drew upon successful examples of nuanced and evidence-based strategies from other countries, urging South Africa to follow similar paths. Their issue was not with the goals of the Bill but with its structure. They objected to the single legislation encompassing both tobacco and electronic delivery systems.

Concerns About the Bill’s Impact

The residents expressed concern about Clause 9 (5) of the Bill that proposes banning the sale of tobacco products and electronic delivery systems online, or via mail or courier services. They labeled this proposition as impractical. They contended that such legislation would negatively affect e-commerce, an expanding platform of economic exchange and a significant economic driver, leading to detrimental economic outcomes.

Those who opposed the Bill also highlighted that Clause 12 does not specify funding and monitoring procedures. The public hearings attracted a wide range of opinions, from ardent supporters of the Bill to those who rejected it outright.

Mixed Perspectives on the Bill

On one hand, those in favor of the Bill shared personal experiences of loss due to preventable diseases such as cancer and tuberculosis, which are often induced by tobacco consumption. They viewed this Bill as a powerful deterrent to youth, preventing high consumption of tobacco products.

They further suggested that the Bill could potentially redirect significant resources currently used to treat smoking-related illnesses towards fortifying the healthcare system or financing other social initiatives. Supporters appreciated the proposal in Clause 7 for graphic displays illustrating the severe health, economic, and social consequences of tobacco consumption. They were of the belief that such images would influence informed decision-making, thereby potentially reducing usage.

Supporters also contended that the Bill would protect non-smokers from second-hand smoke inhalation, an issue they felt was currently ignored by smokers.

However, not everyone held this positive perspective of the Bill. Its critics emphasized the potential detriment to small-scale tobacco producers and traders, arguing that the Bill might jeopardize their livelihoods, especially in the context of increasing unemployment.

Critics also voiced concerns about an expected surge in the market for illicit cigarettes due to the implementation of the Bill. They suggested that these illegal cigarettes might not conform to manufacturing standards, potentially posing an even greater health risk to smokers.

Moreover, critics underscored the potential adverse impact on the economy, pointing out how the tobacco industry significantly contributes to the nation’s economy via tax revenue and job creation. They argued that the implementation of the Bill might decrease the legal sale of tobacco products, leading to a reduction in tax collection and increased job losses.

The committee wrapped up the Eastern Cape segment of the hearings with a final session in East London. Residents of the Buffalo City Metropolitan Municipality were invited to express their perspectives on the Bill, adding to the complex and ongoing dialogue.

Previous Story

Durban Super Giants Outshine Paarl Royals in SA20 Cricket League

Next Story

A New Dawn: South African Parliament Resumes for 2024

Latest from Blog

Cape Town’s Commitment to Infrastructure Renewal

Cape Town is on a mission to fix its roads, pavements, and water systems to make the city even better for its residents. Since November 2024, teams have been hard at work repairing urgent water issues and upgrading the sidewalks and curbs, showing how much the city cares about keeping the water flowing smoothly. Although there have been some bumps along the way, with delays and frustrations for some locals, Cape Town is focused on getting the job done quickly and effectively. With a big budget of R55 million, the city is determined to improve over 4,000 square meters of streets, blending practicality with a touch of beauty to keep its charm alive. Each completed project is like adding a colorful brushstroke to Cape Town’s vibrant story!

Resilience Amid Flames: Cape Town’s Response to Devastating Fires

Cape Town is bravely fighting back against the wildfires that devastated its informal settlements, which left many families homeless. Local leaders are quickly providing emergency housing and asking for more support to act faster during crises. The community is coming together, working with relief groups to help those in need, and showing incredible strength and hope. As they rebuild their lives, Cape Town’s spirit shines through, proving that even in tough times, people can unite to create a brighter future.

Transforming Policing in South Africa’s Northern Cape

In South Africa’s Northern Cape, a heartwarming initiative is changing how police treat victims of genderbased violence. They are creating special Victim Friendly Rooms in police stations, where survivors can feel safe and cared for. This project, led by Lieutenant General Koliswa Otola and her team, aims to build trust within the community and make victims feel supported. By using technology and compassionate approaches, police are not just enforcing laws; they are becoming a source of comfort and strength for those in need.

Crime and Justice in the Western Cape: A Complex Narrative

In the Western Cape of South Africa, crime and justice form a complicated story filled with both struggles and hope. High levels of drugrelated crime and illegal guns create big challenges for communities, but law enforcement, like the AntiEconomic Crimes Task Team, works hard to make things safer. A recent operation in Beacon Valley led to the arrest of four suspects and uncovered a stash of drugs and a gun, showing the ongoing battle against crime. This situation reflects not just individual actions but deeper social issues that affect many lives, highlighting the need for a fair and understanding justice system. Through this, we see a blend of resilience, culture, and the community’s strong spirit striving for a better future.

Spreading Holiday Cheer: Firefighters Bring Joy to Children

In December 2024, firefighters brightened the holidays for children in care facilities by delivering wrapped gifts with big smiles. Partnering with Pick n Pay, they spread joy and gratitude after receiving support during a tough summer of wildfires. Each visit was a heartwarming reminder of kindness, as firefighters became symbols of generosity, teaching kids about empathy and community spirit. This joyful initiative shows how simple acts of giving can light up lives and strengthen bonds in the community.