South Africa’s Legal Battle Against Israel: A Genocide Case at the International Court of Justice

3 mins read
south africa israel

South Africa has taken Israel to the International Court of Justice, accusing it of genocide against Palestinians. Four of South Africa’s top lawyers, including Tembeka Ngcukaitobi and John Dugard, will represent the nation’s case. The landmark case highlights the importance of legal expertise in addressing global issues and has the potential to shape the future of international law and human rights, with the world watching closely.

South Africa has brought a case against Israel before the International Court of Justice, accusing it of committing genocide against Palestinians. Four of South Africa’s top lawyers, including Tembeka Ngcukaitobi and John Dugard, will represent the nation’s case. This landmark case highlights the importance of legal expertise in addressing global issues and has the potential to shape the future of international law and human rights.

Newsletter

Stay Informed • Cape Town

Get breaking news, events, and local stories delivered to your inbox daily. All the news that matters in under 5 minutes.

Join 10,000+ readers
No spam, unsubscribe anytime

The International Court of Justice is set to hear a grave case brought forward by South Africa against Israel, charging it with the allegation of genocide committed against Palestinians. South Africa, in an effort to demonstrate its legal prowess, has selected four of its most esteemed lawyers to represent the nation’s case. Noteworthy, among the legal practitioners are Sarah Pudifin-Jones, Lerato Zikalala, and Tshidiso Ramogale, who will be joined by internationally reputable advisors, Blinne Ní Ghrálaigh KC and Vaughan Lowe KC from the United Kingdom.

Leading Legal Minds in the Spotlight

Prominent among the lawyers representing South Africa is Tembeka Ngcukaitobi SC, who gained recognition in 2016 when he defended the Economic Freedom Fighters and successfully petitioned for the release of the state capture report. A respected figure within the Johannesburg Bar, Ngcukaitobi specialises in areas including competition, labour, constitutional, and commercial law. His exceptional skill were rewarded with the silk status in 2020 – a high honour reserved for a select few.

Alongside him, the team will also be graced by the presence of John Dugard SC, an internationally acclaimed professor and lawyer renowned for his expertise in international law and human rights. As per his United Nations biography, Dugard has been part of the UN International Law Commission since 1997 and has served as the Special Rapporteur on Diplomatic Protection to the Commission starting from 2000. His impressive career history includes roles such as Judge ad hoc in the International Court of Justice and Special Rapporteur to the UN Commission on Human Rights on violation of Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law in the Occupied Palestinian Territory from 2001 onwards.

Key Contributors to the Case

Max du Plessis SC, a Durban-based lawyer associated with Ubunye Chambers, will contribute his profound knowledge of international law to the case. He provides counsel to governments, international bodies, and NGOs on a multitude of matters. His expertise is often called upon in cases presented before the International Criminal Court, the African Commission on Human and Peoples Rights, the SADC Tribunal, and the East African Court of Justice. Du Plessis’s practice areas encompass public law, human rights, international law, and competition law.

Completing this legal supergroup is Adila Hassim SC, a key figure in socio-economic rights matters. Hassim was at the forefront of the counsel in the Life Esidimeni arbitration case. Additionally, she holds esteemed positions as the co-founder and Head of Litigation at Section27 and as a co-founder of Corruption Watch.

The Monumental Case and its Implications

Every individual in South Africa’s legal team is a veteran in their respective field, preparing to present a case fraught with political, historical, and humanitarian complexities. The court proceedings are bound to gain worldwide attention due to the serious allegations and their potential implications on an international scale.

The case provides each of the legal practitioners involved an opportunity to apply their expertise to a matter of profound international significance. Their collective efforts have the potential to shape the future of international law and human rights, reinforcing the importance of their roles in this pivotal case. As they navigate the intricate legal landscape and present their arguments, they not only represent South Africa but also embody the universal fight for justice.

The case symbolizes the ongoing struggle for human rights recognition and the quest for justice. The discussions at the International Court of Justice underscore the importance of legal proficiency in addressing global issues. With the world’s eyes on them, these legal powerhouses are certain to leave an indelible mark on international law’s history.

1. What is the case that South Africa has brought against Israel?

South Africa has taken Israel to the International Court of Justice, accusing it of genocide against Palestinians.

2. Who will represent South Africa in the case?

Four of South Africa’s top lawyers, including Tembeka Ngcukaitobi and John Dugard, will represent the nation’s case. Other notable lawyers include Sarah Pudifin-Jones, Lerato Zikalala, and Tshidiso Ramogale.

3. Who is Tembeka Ngcukaitobi SC?

Tembeka Ngcukaitobi SC is a prominent lawyer from South Africa who specialises in areas including competition, labour, constitutional, and commercial law. He gained recognition in 2016 when he defended the Economic Freedom Fighters and successfully petitioned for the release of the state capture report.

4. Who is John Dugard SC?

John Dugard SC is an internationally acclaimed professor and lawyer renowned for his expertise in international law and human rights. He has served as the Special Rapporteur on Diplomatic Protection to the UN International Law Commission and as the Special Rapporteur to the UN Commission on Human Rights on violation of Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law in the Occupied Palestinian Territory.

5. What are the potential implications of the case?

The case has the potential to shape the future of international law and human rights. It underscores the importance of legal proficiency in addressing global issues and represents the ongoing struggle for human rights recognition and the quest for justice.

6. Who else is involved in the case?

Other key contributors to the case include Max du Plessis SC, a Durban-based lawyer associated with Ubunye Chambers, and Adila Hassim SC, a key figure in socio-economic rights matters and co-founder of Corruption Watch.

Lerato Mokena is a Cape Town-based journalist who covers the city’s vibrant arts and culture scene with a focus on emerging voices from Khayelitsha to the Bo-Kaap. Born and raised at the foot of Table Mountain, she brings an insider’s eye to how creativity shapes—and is shaped by—South Africa’s complex social landscape. When she’s not chasing stories, Lerato can be found surfing Muizenberg’s gentle waves or debating politics over rooibos in her grandmother’s Gugulethu kitchen.

Previous Story

On The Hunt: Kaizer Chiefs’ Search for a New Coach

Next Story

Hollywood’s Action Elite: A Hidden Digital Roundtable

Latest from Blog

Dawn, Dirt and Dinner: A Willowvale Kitchen Without Walls

In Willowvale, farmers cleverly plant in manurefilled pits to save water and feed the soil. They also build special ditches to catch rainwater, making sure not a single drop goes to waste. Cooking happens outdoors, over crackling fires, using fresh food grown right there. They even turn old things into new cooking tools. It’s all about living close to the earth and making every bit count, showing a deep love for nature.

Cape Town Quietly Rewrites the Rules Between Tradition and the State

Cape Town is cleverly changing how it supports traditional initiation camps. They now treat these camps like temporary city areas, providing water, toilets, and trash pickup. This helps keep everyone safe and healthy, using smart data to track everything. It’s a quiet revolution, making sure old traditions fit smoothly into modern city life, and other cities are starting to notice this clever plan.

South Africa Plays Hardball on Hoof-and-Mouth: A Five-Year Blitz to Reopen R7 Billion in Beef Trade

South Africa is launching a massive fiveyear plan to crush FootandMouth Disease for good. They’re upgrading labs, getting tons of vaccines, and working with villages to tag and track every animal. This tough new strategy, backed by big money, aims to reopen a R7 billion beef trade with countries like China and the EU. They’re using strict rules, new tech, and even special meetings with local leaders to make sure no sick animal slips through. It’s a fullon war to protect their cattle and bring back their valuable beef exports!

South Africa’s Gateways in November 2025: 3,1 Million Footprints in 30 Days

In November 2025, South Africa saw a massive 3.1 million people cross its borders. This huge number of visitors, especially 2.37 million noncitizens, made it the busiest November for foreign entries since before COVID hit in 2019. It was like a river of people flowing in, showing how popular South Africa had become again.