The Bromwell Street eviction case in Cape Town is a dispute between residents and a private owner, which has become a citywide concern. Residents demand governmentprovided emergency housing in specific regions when facing private eviction. The case challenges the feasibility and reasonability of such an obligation and poses a significant strain on public resources. Cape Town’s housing policy champions social housing on city land and has produced over 3,500 units, with more properties being prepared for release. The case’s implications will influence future discourse on housing policies and strategies worldwide.