The Blurring Lines of Digital Influence: A Controversial Incident in South Africa

3 mins read
digital influence controversy Cape Town

Influencer and podcaster Mitchelle Karoro caused controversy in South Africa when she posted on social media about her domestic worker’s reluctance to work during the festive season, leading to public backlash and a nationwide discussion about the dignity and entitlements of domestic workers. Many social media users criticised Karoro for her disregard for her worker’s entitlements, highlighting the importance of fair treatment of domestic workers and their rights, as stated in the Basic Conditions of Employment Act’s Domestic Worker Sector. The incident has sparked an ongoing discourse about the treatment of domestic workers and the power of influencers in shaping societal standards.

The Blurring Lines of Digital Influence: A Controversial Incident in South Africa

Newsletter

Stay Informed • Cape Town

Get breaking news, events, and local stories delivered to your inbox daily. All the news that matters in under 5 minutes.

Join 10,000+ readers
No spam, unsubscribe anytime

A social media proclamation by influencer and podcaster, Mitchelle Karoro, sparked a nationwide discussion surrounding the dignity and entitlements of domestic workers in South Africa. Her posts revealed her quandary over her domestic worker’s reluctance to resume work during the festive season and led to public backlash, bringing attention to the struggles and rights of domestic workers. The ongoing discourse emphasizes the necessity for fair treatment of domestic workers.

The Controversy Sparks

Within the digital domain, the line separating personal from public frequently becomes ambiguous, resulting in unforeseen disputes. A recent controversy instigating heated discussions amongst South Africans originates from a social media proclamation by influencer and podcaster, Mitchelle Karoro. Her statements have incited nationwide dialogue surrounding the dignity and entitlements of domestic workers.

Mitchelle Karoro, who communicates with thousands via her podcast and X account, disclosed a private conflict that unintentionally drew attention to the wider topic of domestic workers’ entitlements. It appears her domestic worker was reluctant to resume work during the festive season – a situation Ms. Karoro deemed unacceptable.

She revealed her quandary on her X account, stating, “I informed my helper today that she will get a break only on Christmas Day and Boxing Day. She must return for New Year’s since we are planning a group celebration with friends.” When her domestic worker expressed the wish to take both holidays off, Ms. Karoro issued a choice – work on New Year’s or forfeit her job. The worker’s silence in response led Ms. Karoro to contemplate firing her to prevent “unnecessary drama and stress.”

The Public Backlash

The posts, which quickly spread across the internet, struck a chord with many South Africans, stunned at Ms. Karoro’s “unreasonable” demand. Responses varied from shock to outrage, as social media users expressed their disapproval of her presumptuousness and disregard for her domestic worker’s entitlements.

One user, @Ziggy_Diver1, commented, “She stays with you throughout the year, and you believe she doesn’t deserve a break on both days?” He proposed employing a house watcher or child-minder as an alternative. Another user, @dramadelinquent, reminded Ms. Karoro that New Year’s is a public holiday, and if she insists on her domestic worker working, she ought to pay double her daily wages. @kokkyt chided the influencer for refusing her helper festive leave, asserting that it’s a time for family and the wish to spend it with dear ones should be honored.

The public anger was perfectly summarised in a tweet from @zwidenyapT featuring an image captioned, “You are an evil person.” This tweet rapidly gained popularity, adding fuel to the growing backlash.

A Bigger Cause

In the midst of the social media tempest, it’s crucial to highlight the rights of domestic workers as stated in the Basic Conditions of Employment Act’s Domestic Worker Sector. As per the Act, domestic workers are granted certain privileges, which comprise the right to annual leave and public holiday wages.

The Mitchelle Karoro incident serves as a stark reminder of the profound influence of influencers and their extensive platforms on societal standards and dialogues. Even as the uproar caused by Ms. Karoro’s tweets continues to echo through social media, one thing stands out – this dispute has highlighted the struggles of domestic workers and underscored the significance of their rights, propelling an important discussion into the public domain.

Emphasising Fair Treatment

The ongoing discourse emphasises the necessity for equitable treatment of domestic workers. As this conversation continues, it’s imperative that domestic workers’ rights are maintained, venerated, and fervently defended. As we progress, we hope this episode acts as a trigger for positive transformation in how we regard and treat domestic workers.

What was the controversy surrounding Mitchelle Karoro’s social media post?

Mitchelle Karoro’s social media post sparked controversy in South Africa when she revealed on her account that her domestic worker was reluctant to work during the festive season, leading to public backlash and a nationwide discussion about the dignity and entitlements of domestic workers.

What was the public response to Karoro’s post?

The public response to Karoro’s post varied from shock to outrage, with many social media users criticising her for her disregard for her domestic worker’s entitlements and proposing alternative solutions.

What are the rights of domestic workers as stated in the Basic Conditions of Employment Act?

Domestic workers are granted certain privileges as per the Basic Conditions of Employment Act’s Domestic Worker Sector, which comprise the right to annual leave and public holiday wages.

What does the Mitchelle Karoro incident serve as a reminder of?

The Mitchelle Karoro incident serves as a stark reminder of the profound influence of influencers and their extensive platforms on societal standards and dialogues.

What is the ongoing discourse surrounding the incident?

The ongoing discourse emphasises the necessity for equitable treatment of domestic workers and underscores the significance of their rights, propelling an important discussion into the public domain.

How can we positively transform the way we regard and treat domestic workers?

As we progress, it’s imperative that domestic workers’ rights are maintained, venerated, and fervently defended. We hope this episode acts as a trigger for positive transformation in how we regard and treat domestic workers.

Sizwe Dlamini is a Cape Town-based journalist who chronicles the city’s evolving food scene, from boeka picnics in the Bo-Kaap to seafood braais in Khayelitsha. Raised on the slopes of Table Mountain, he still starts every morning with a walk to the kramat in Constantia before heading out to discover whose grandmother is dishing up the best smoorsnoek that day.

Previous Story

Hollywood Star Cuba Gooding Jr. Faces Legal Challenges: Lawsuits Filed by Two Women

Next Story

The 2023 Netball World Cup: A Dazzling Display of Athletic Superiority

Latest from Blog

Forty Metres of Air: The Morning Kiteboarding Rewrote Physics

Hugo Wigglesworth, a young kiteboarder, defied gravity and rewrote the record books by soaring an incredible 40 meters into the air. He used powerful winds, a perfectly timed jump off a wave, and special gear to achieve this amazing feat. His careful planning and hundreds of practice runs made him fly higher than anyone before, showing the world what’s possible in kiteboarding.

Airbnb Under Fire: How Cape Town’s Housing Crunch Became a Tourism Blame-Game

Cape Town’s housing woes are NOT really Airbnb’s fault, even though a viral photo tried to blame them! The real problem is that not enough homes are being built, and lots of new people are moving to the city. Getting building permits takes forever, making homes expensive. Airbnb brings in lots of money and jobs, and even if all Airbnbs disappeared, it wouldn’t fix the big housing shortage. The city needs to build more homes and make it easier to do so, not just point fingers at tourists.

Cape Town’s Hottest Tables: Where Summer Tastes Like Salt, Smoke and Midnight Vinyl

Cape Town’s new restaurants are super exciting, offering amazing tastes from the ocean, farms, and even old recipes. Places like Amura serve unique sea dishes, while Tannin has a huge wine list and tiny plates. Café Sofi bakes heavenly pastries, Beach Buns makes awesome burgers, and Le Bistrot de JAN mixes French and South African flavors. These spots let you taste the city’s lively food scene, from fancy dinners to casual beach eats, making every meal an adventure.

Between Concrete and Current – Four Inland Hearts Meet the Indian Ocean

This article tells a beautiful story of four South Africans from inland places who see the Indian Ocean for the very first time. For many, the sea is just a picture, far away and hard to reach. But when these brave people finally touch the salty water, it changes them deeply. They feel the ocean’s power, taste its salt, and understand that this huge, blue world is now a part of their own story, breaking down old ideas about who can connect with the sea.