The Fight for Fairness: A Tale of Medical Misdiagnosis and A Family's Pursuit for Justice - Cape Town Today
Customize Consent Preferences

We use cookies to help you navigate efficiently and perform certain functions. You will find detailed information about all cookies under each consent category below.

The cookies that are categorized as "Necessary" are stored on your browser as they are essential for enabling the basic functionalities of the site. ... 

Always Active

Necessary cookies are required to enable the basic features of this site, such as providing secure log-in or adjusting your consent preferences. These cookies do not store any personally identifiable data.

No cookies to display.

Functional cookies help perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collecting feedback, and other third-party features.

No cookies to display.

Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics such as the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.

No cookies to display.

Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.

No cookies to display.

Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with customized advertisements based on the pages you visited previously and to analyze the effectiveness of the ad campaigns.

No cookies to display.

The Fight for Fairness: A Tale of Medical Misdiagnosis and A Family’s Pursuit for Justice

3 mins read
medical misdiagnosis legal fight

The Fight for Fairness is a story of a family’s pursuit for justice following a fatal medical misdiagnosis that resulted in the death of their loved one. The woman’s incorrect diagnosis led to the amputation of her leg, which her family insists was a fatal misdiagnosis. Despite their loss, the family continues to fight for compensation and accountability from the medical profession, highlighting the importance of precise diagnostics and justice in healthcare.

The Fight for Fairness: A Tale of Medical Misdiagnosis and A Family’s Pursuit for Justice

A family’s pursuit for justice following a fatal medical misdiagnosis resulting in the death of a family member unfolds in the presence of the Supreme Court of Appeal in South Africa. The woman’s incorrect diagnosis led to an above-knee amputation, which her family insists was a fatal misdiagnosis. The family continued the legal fight, pursuing compensation for their financial and emotional distress.

The narrative of a family’s relentless pursuit for justice following a tragic medical misdiagnosis resulting in the untimely death of a family member, unfolds in the presence of the Supreme Court of Appeal in South Africa. The family challenges the Western Cape Health Department’s conduct of the case in this dramatic saga.

The Initial Diagnosis

In the heart of Cape Metropolis, a woman, whose identity remains concealed due to confidentiality, sought medical help for acute leg pain at a local health clinic in Tafelsig. A Type 2 diabetic, she was initially diagnosed with gout. This diagnosis, even after multiple visits to different hospitals, marked the tragic start of a harrowing journey sadly.

The woman was later transferred to the Groote Schuur Hospital. It was here, to her utter disbelief and horror, that she was informed about the necessity of an amputation above the knee. The amputation of the woman’s leg followed, which her family insists, resulted from a fatal misdiagnosis.

The Legal Fight

Tzvi Brivik, the director of Malcolm Lyons and Brivik Inc., the law firm representing the woman and her family, voiced his sympathy in a statement, “Our client, a Type 2 diabetic, tragically received a misdiagnosis after multiple consultations at an array of hospitals managed by the Minister of Health.”

The incorrect diagnosis and subsequent amputation had a severe impact on the woman’s health, which rapidly declined. According to Brivik, “The outcome of the misdiagnosis, over a considerable duration, was an above-knee amputation. This amputation was the catalyst for her health’s rapid deterioration.”

The woman initiated legal action against the MEC for Health, intending to win compensation for anticipated future medical expenses, as assessed by various medical specialists. The objective was to modify the relevant legal documents in line with these evaluated expenses.

The Family’s Struggle

Regrettably, the woman succumbed to her deteriorating health before the conclusion of her case. Following their loss, her bereaved family took up the legal fight, pursuing compensation for their financial and emotional distress.

The family’s fight for justice has now progressed to the Supreme Court of Appeal, the country’s highest court. Brivik and his team are presently waiting for a hearing date from the court, expected in the third or fourth term.

This case puts a spotlight on crucial healthcare concerns, the necessity of precise diagnostics, and the demand for accountability in the medical fraternity. It emphasizes the catastrophic effects of medical misdiagnosis on patients and their families, further underscoring the crucial role justice plays in our society.

As the family continues their legal pursuit, we can only aspire that their endeavours will result in a fundamental change in the medical profession. Their struggle is a stark reminder of the profound influence of medical decisions on patients’ lives and the inherent responsibility that accompanies the medical profession.

Despite the tragedy, this tale also exhibits the resilience of the human spirit in the face of adversity, the quest for justice, and the ongoing struggle for accountability in a world where medical misdiagnosis can lead to irrevocable outcomes.

What is the Fight for Fairness story about?

The Fight for Fairness is a story of a family’s pursuit for justice following a fatal medical misdiagnosis that led to the amputation of their loved one’s leg, which they insist was a fatal misdiagnosis.

What was the initial diagnosis for the woman?

The woman was initially diagnosed with gout after seeking medical help for acute leg pain at a local health clinic in Tafelsig.

What was the legal action taken by the woman?

The woman initiated legal action against the MEC for Health to win compensation for anticipated future medical expenses as assessed by various medical specialists.

What happened to the woman before the conclusion of her case?

Regrettably, the woman succumbed to her deteriorating health before the conclusion of her case.

Who took up the legal fight after the woman’s passing?

Following the woman’s passing, her bereaved family took up the legal fight, pursuing compensation for their financial and emotional distress.

What does this case highlight in healthcare?

This case highlights the necessity of precise diagnostics, demand for accountability in the medical fraternity, and the catastrophic effects of medical misdiagnosis on patients and their families. It underscores the crucial role justice plays in our society and the profound influence of medical decisions on patients’ lives.

Previous Story

Significant Increment in Social Security Grants: A Ray of Hope for South Africans

Next Story

Siya Kolisi: A Pillar of Inspiration in Rugby’s Pantheon

Latest from Blog

The Rise of Vaping Among South African Teenagers

Vaping is quickly becoming a popular habit among South African teenagers, drawn by sweet fruity flavors, flashy packaging, and the buzz on social media. Many teens vape to fit in with friends, feel cool and rebellious, or to escape stress and anxiety. However, what seems like harmless fun can quickly turn into addiction, affecting their health and wellbeing. Despite the risks, vaping is often misunderstood, making it harder for families and schools to stop this growing trend. It’s a serious challenge that needs everyone—parents, teachers, and leaders—to work together to protect young people’s futures.

South African Agriculture and the Changing Winds of Trade

Since 2000, the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) has helped South African farmers sell fruits like avocados, wine, and citrus to the United States without paying extra taxes. This chance boosted farming communities, especially small farmers and women, by opening up new markets and encouraging growth. But recent U.S. tariffs threaten these gains, making it harder for farmers to compete and putting many livelihoods at risk. Still, South African farmers remain strong and hopeful, working hard to face these new challenges and keep their communities alive.

Trapped Abroad: Ashley Oosthuizen’s Journey Through Thailand’s Legal Labyrinth

Ashley Oosthuizen, a young South African woman, went to Thailand chasing her dreams but ended up trapped in a nightmare. After unknowingly signing for a package with illegal drugs, she was arrested and sentenced to over 13 years in prison, despite being innocent. Her mother moved to Thailand to fight for her, sharing Ashley’s story with the world and gaining support. Even when the real criminal confessed, the Thai courts kept Ashley behind bars. Her story is a powerful reminder of how quickly life can change and the risks travelers face in foreign countries.

Shadows Along the Hennops: Three SAPS Officers Vanish and a River Gives Up Its Secrets

In April 2025, three South African police officers disappeared during a trip and were later found dead near the Hennops River, along with two others. Their white car vanished into the river’s dark, swirling waters, hiding clues and sparking a deep mystery. Families and the public mourned, demanding answers amid fears of foul play. The quiet river, once peaceful, now holds heavy secrets and reminds the nation of the dangers police face and the urgent need for justice.

Cape Town’s Boatbuilding: Crafting a Legacy on the Waterfront

Cape Town’s boatbuilding industry is a shining example of skill and tradition mixed with new technology. It creates beautiful, strong boats that are loved worldwide and supports thousands of jobs in the city. But now, new tariffs on exports, especially to the US, threaten this important work and the people who depend on it. Despite these challenges, boatbuilders, city leaders, and innovators are coming together to protect this proud craft. Their passion and teamwork fuel hope that Cape Town’s boatbuilding legacy will sail on strong into the future.