The Palatable Controversy: A Stir in the Culinary World

3 mins read
food content creators south african influencers

The culinary world is abuzz with controversy as South African food content creators Onezwa Mbola and Nara Smith face off over allegations of imitation on TikTok. Mbola accused Smith of copying her unique meal ideas, particularly in the preparation and presentation of certain dishes. The brewing tension reached a boiling point when Smith uploaded a video of herself making boba tea, a similar beverage to Mbola’s with a unique guava leaf twist, leading to accusations of plagiarism. The incident highlights the importance of recognizing and honoring originality in the creative industry.

The Palatable Controversy: A Stir in the Culinary World – A brewing tension amongst food content creators has escalated after allegations of imitation were casted by Onezwa Mbola against Nara Smith, insinuating that she has been imitating her unique ideas on the popular platform, TikTok. The heart of this squabble lies within the conception and presentation of particular dishes that Smith is purported to have copied from Mbola.

Newsletter

Stay Informed • Cape Town

Get breaking news, events, and local stories delivered to your inbox daily. All the news that matters in under 5 minutes.

Join 10,000+ readers
No spam, unsubscribe anytime

In the vibrant universe of food content creators, a heated disagreement is unfolding. It involves two influential South African figures, Onezwa Mbola and Nara Smith. Mbola, a former participant of MasterChef SA, has casted allegations against Smith, insinuating that she has been imitating her unique ideas on the popular platform, TikTok. The heart of this squabble lies within the conception and presentation of particular dishes that Smith is purported to have copied from Mbola.

Brewing Tension Amongst Food Content Creators

Both Mbola and Smith are widely commended for their ability to concoct meals from scratch, their soothing voiceovers acting as a gastronomic guide for their audience. Their peaceful cohabitation in the food creation space, however, was disrupted when Smith uploaded a video of herself preparing boba tea. This incident occurred shortly after Mbola had posted her rendition of the same beverage.

The video Smith posted carried the caption “What’s your drink order? #easyrecipes #homecooking #fypツ #drink #boba #cravings”. In contrast, a few days prior, Mbola had shared a comparable video, wherein she was observed making a similar beverage, but with a unique touch of guava leaves. In her video, she captioned it as “• Guava Boba: guava leaf tea, guava infused goats milk • goats cheese, mushroom, and spinach galette.”

The resemblances did not escape the eyes of their observant South African followers who began drawing parallels between their content. They alleged that Smith was plagiarizing Mbola’s creative work. The boba tea incident amplified the accusation. The followers have grown more convinced that Smith is duplicating Mbola’s distinctive style.

Accusations and Allegations: The Boba Tea Incident

A staunch defender of Mbola weighed in her perspective on the issue, stating, “This is Onezwa, she is the creator that people have been speculating Nara Smith has been stealing from. Onezwa is a South African woman who grows and forages her own food and genuinely makes her meals from SCRATCH! Y’all should go support”. This sentiment was reiterated by many, leading to a wave of support for Mbola.

Another follower claimed, “Nara steals content and not just from Onezwa. Tini posted her making Nutella from scratch, and a week later, Nara posted hers. Nobody ever truly owns a recipe, but she must acknowledge the creators who inspired her videos, it can’t always just be “cravings.” Another chimed in, “I believe the allegations. These so-called influencers do it all the time & they don’t expect the micro-influencer to say anything since their following is small to gain traction. I’m glad Onezwa spoke up.”

Reflections and Repercussions: A Conversation with Onezwa Mbola

In the wake of the controversy, Onezwa shared her personal thoughts on the matter in an interview with The Citizen. She revealed her uncertainty about whether Smith would cease her alleged copying. She highlighted that numerous other people have claimed that Smith had copied them as well. Onezwa was adamant that she was not the only victim. Despite the controversy, she affirmed her determination to persist in creating and sharing content on TikTok and Instagram.

This incident serves as an eye-opener in the creative industry. While inspiration is a pivotal part of the creative journey, it’s equally essential to recognize and honor the originality of others. After all, the essence of creating lies in bringing something novel to the table, enhancing the existing treasury of ideas, rather than simply replicating them.

What is the Palatable Controversy?

It is a brewing tension amongst food content creators. Onezwa Mbola accused Nara Smith of copying her unique meal ideas on TikTok, leading to allegations of plagiarism.

What is the heart of the squabble between Onezwa Mbola and Nara Smith?

The heart of the squabble lies within the conception and presentation of particular dishes that Smith is purported to have copied from Mbola.

What is the Boba Tea incident?

Smith uploaded a video of herself making boba tea, a similar beverage to Mbola’s with a unique guava leaf twist, leading to accusations of plagiarism.

What are the allegations against Nara Smith?

The followers alleged that Smith was plagiarizing Mbola’s creative work. The Boba Tea incident amplified the accusation. The followers have grown more convinced that Smith is duplicating Mbola’s distinctive style.

What has Onezwa Mbola said about the controversy?

In an interview with The Citizen, she revealed her uncertainty about whether Smith would cease her alleged copying. Despite the controversy, she affirmed her determination to persist in creating and sharing content on TikTok and Instagram.

What does this incident reveal about the creative industry?

This incident serves as an eye-opener in the creative industry. While inspiration is a pivotal part of the creative journey, it’s equally essential to recognize and honor the originality of others.

Thabo Sebata is a Cape Town-based journalist who covers the intersection of politics and daily life in South Africa's legislative capital, bringing grassroots perspectives to parliamentary reporting from his upbringing in Gugulethu. When not tracking policy shifts or community responses, he finds inspiration hiking Table Mountain's trails and documenting the city's evolving food scene in Khayelitsha and Bo-Kaap. His work has appeared in leading South African publications, where his distinctive voice captures the complexities of a nation rebuilding itself.

Previous Story

Lloyd Harris: Perseverance Personified at Wimbledon

Next Story

The Revitalization of Geelsloot Ponds: A Catalyst for Urban Change in Somerset West

Latest from Blog

Forty Metres of Air: The Morning Kiteboarding Rewrote Physics

Hugo Wigglesworth, a young kiteboarder, defied gravity and rewrote the record books by soaring an incredible 40 meters into the air. He used powerful winds, a perfectly timed jump off a wave, and special gear to achieve this amazing feat. His careful planning and hundreds of practice runs made him fly higher than anyone before, showing the world what’s possible in kiteboarding.

Airbnb Under Fire: How Cape Town’s Housing Crunch Became a Tourism Blame-Game

Cape Town’s housing woes are NOT really Airbnb’s fault, even though a viral photo tried to blame them! The real problem is that not enough homes are being built, and lots of new people are moving to the city. Getting building permits takes forever, making homes expensive. Airbnb brings in lots of money and jobs, and even if all Airbnbs disappeared, it wouldn’t fix the big housing shortage. The city needs to build more homes and make it easier to do so, not just point fingers at tourists.

Cape Town’s Hottest Tables: Where Summer Tastes Like Salt, Smoke and Midnight Vinyl

Cape Town’s new restaurants are super exciting, offering amazing tastes from the ocean, farms, and even old recipes. Places like Amura serve unique sea dishes, while Tannin has a huge wine list and tiny plates. Café Sofi bakes heavenly pastries, Beach Buns makes awesome burgers, and Le Bistrot de JAN mixes French and South African flavors. These spots let you taste the city’s lively food scene, from fancy dinners to casual beach eats, making every meal an adventure.

Between Concrete and Current – Four Inland Hearts Meet the Indian Ocean

This article tells a beautiful story of four South Africans from inland places who see the Indian Ocean for the very first time. For many, the sea is just a picture, far away and hard to reach. But when these brave people finally touch the salty water, it changes them deeply. They feel the ocean’s power, taste its salt, and understand that this huge, blue world is now a part of their own story, breaking down old ideas about who can connect with the sea.