The Significance of Electoral Commissions in Modern Democracy

4 mins read
electoral commissions south african elections

Electoral commissions are vital in ensuring fair and open elections in democratic societies. The Electoral Commission of South Africa faced challenges during the 2024 election, including long lines, technical issues, and poorly prepared staff, leading to calls for improved election management and eroding voter confidence. The successful conduct of an election must instill confidence and trust among the electorate, and the IEC must address concerns to uphold the principles of fairness and freedom in the voting process. Citizens can voice their concerns through a feedback form to aim for a seamless and efficient voting experience for all.

What is the significance of electoral commissions in modern democracy?

Electoral commissions play a crucial role in ensuring just and open elections in contemporary democratic societies. The Electoral Commission of South Africa (IEC) faced significant challenges during the 2024 election, with long lines, technical problems, and poorly prepared staff leading to mounting calls for improved election management and eroding voter confidence. The successful and fair conduct of an election extends beyond just voting; it must instill a sense of confidence and trust among the electorate.

Newsletter

Stay Informed • Cape Town

Get breaking news, events, and local stories delivered to your inbox daily. All the news that matters in under 5 minutes.

Join 10,000+ readers
No spam, unsubscribe anytime

In contemporary democratic societies, the function of electoral commissions is incredibly significant. Tasked with overseeing just and open elections, the Electoral Commission of South Africa (IEC) has recently found itself in the midst of controversy. The election day of 2024, a vital turning point in the nation’s political evolution, was tarnished by a variety of issues from long lines and technical problems to poorly prepared staff.

The voting process, slated to end at 21h00, saw voters still stuck in lines that spiderwebbed around numerous blocks, causing undue stress for those enthusiastic about practicing their democratic right. The widespread chaos even led to an unexpected commendation for the Economic Freedom Front (EFF) leader, Julius Malema, who delivered a blistering critique of the IEC. Following a more than three-hour wait to cast his vote in the Seshego township, Malema noted that the apparent sluggishness of the voting process could possibly facilitate election rigging.

The South African Electoral Commission’s Challenges

Echoing the sentiments of numerous voters, Malema underscored the confusion caused by the three-ballot system and the alarming absence of privacy at polling stations. The populace took to various social platforms to express their grievances regarding the IEC’s conduct, contributing to the mounting calls for improved election management. I personally endured a three-hour and fifteen-minute wait to cast my vote, seeing the disorganization within the organization up close. In my local polling station, any individual who had re-registered a Section 24A was conspicuously missing from the voter’s roll, inciting further confusion.

In spite of all this, the IEC had been reassuring the public about their readiness for the election weeks in advance. They boasted about advanced voter management systems aimed at eradicating voter fraud. They guaranteed everyone that the voting process was designed to be ‘impossible’ to rig, and that the results would be unquestionably accurate. However, the actual experiences on election day seemed to tell a different story.

IEC’s Response to the Election Day Crisis

Masego Sheburi, IEC Deputy Chief Electoral Officer, acknowledged the plethora of problems that tainted the voting process. Late delivery of materials, technical glitches, and protests in certain regions – these hurdles surfaced as the day progressed. Despite these obstacles, Sheburi asserted that abundant supplies, including over 90 million ballot papers, were on hand and that the voting process would proceed without interruption even if scanners malfunctioned.

Sheburi also underscored that the IEC’s workforce, consisting of over 230,000 individuals, received sufficient training over a four-day period. This training covered logistics, handling, electoral and polling station administration, and the counting process. However, the experiences of voters like myself and political leaders like Malema suggest that this training was insufficient for the magnitude of the event.

The Impact of Disorganization on Voter Confidence

Importantly, the disarray visible during the election does more than merely frustrate voters – it shakes confidence in the process itself. If citizens are forced to wait for three hours or more to cast their vote, their faith in the democratic process can understandably diminish. The IEC must address these concerns, as the successful and fair conduct of an election extends beyond just voting; it must instill a sense of confidence and trust among the electorate.

It is in the spirit of democracy that anyone who had a dissatisfactory experience with the IEC should voice their concerns openly. A voter feedback form is available for this purpose, offering a platform for citizens to express their concerns, complaints, and suggestions. We must aim for an election process that not only upholds the principles of fairness and freedom but also ensures a seamless and efficient voting experience for everyone.

What challenges did the Electoral Commission of South Africa face during the 2024 election?

The Electoral Commission of South Africa faced challenges during the 2024 election, including long lines, technical issues, and poorly prepared staff, leading to calls for improved election management and eroding voter confidence.

What is the role of electoral commissions in modern democracy?

Electoral commissions play a crucial role in ensuring just and open elections in contemporary democratic societies. The successful and fair conduct of an election extends beyond just voting; it must instill a sense of confidence and trust among the electorate.

How did the disorganization during the election impact voter confidence?

The disarray visible during the election does more than merely frustrate voters – it shakes confidence in the process itself. If citizens are forced to wait for three hours or more to cast their vote, their faith in the democratic process can understandably diminish.

What is the IEC’s response to the election day crisis?

Masego Sheburi, IEC Deputy Chief Electoral Officer, acknowledged the plethora of problems that tainted the voting process. Late delivery of materials, technical glitches, and protests in certain regions – these hurdles surfaced as the day progressed. However, Sheburi asserted that the voting process would proceed without interruption even if scanners malfunctioned.

How can citizens voice their concerns about the election process?

A voter feedback form is available for this purpose, offering a platform for citizens to express their concerns, complaints, and suggestions.

What training did the IEC workforce receive for the election?

The IEC’s workforce, consisting of over 230,000 individuals, received sufficient training over a four-day period. This training covered logistics, handling, electoral and polling station administration, and the counting process.

Chloe de Kock is a Cape Town-born journalist who chronicles the city’s evolving food culture, from township braai joints to Constantia vineyards, for the Mail & Guardian and Eat Out. When she’s not interviewing grandmothers about secret bobotie recipes or tracking the impact of drought on winemakers, you’ll find her surfing the mellow breaks at Muizenberg—wetsuit zipped, notebook tucked into her backpack in case the next story floats by.

Previous Story

Unfurling the Cape Town Green Revolution

Next Story

The Ongoing Debate: Balancing Urban Structure and Safety in Cape Town’s Cycling Paths

Latest from Blog

Five Nights, Five Worlds: Galileo’s December Cinema Safari Through the Western Cape

Get ready for Galileo’s December Cinema Safari, where movies come alive in amazing places! Imagine watching action flicks in a garden, or a highflying movie on a helicopter pad. Each night has tasty food, fun activities, and cool surprises that match the film and setting. It’s five nights of pure movie magic under the stars in the Western Cape. Don’t miss this oneofakind outdoor cinema adventure!

From Angels to Banjos: How Cape Town’s 2023 Festive Lights Sparked a Culture War

Cape Town’s 2023 festive lights sparked a big fight! They swapped out old angel decorations for new ones showing banjo players and carnival masks. This made some people very angry because it changed what Christmas felt like. Others thought it was a good way to show off local culture and history, especially the “Kaapse Klopse” tradition. So, a simple light display turned into a huge argument about culture and who gets to decide what the city looks like.

City of Gold, City of Guns: The Mid-Day Murder That Stopped Johannesburg Cold

DJ Warras, a beloved radio star, was tragically murdered in a busy Johannesburg food court. This wasn’t a random robbery, but a planned hit by a ‘reputation guardianship’ gang. These groups extort money from performers and businesses, using violence when people refuse. It seems DJ Warras was killed because he spoke out against them, turning a regular lunch hour into a shocking scene of crime and fear.

Silent Sappers: How a Pin-Sized Beetle Is Redrawing Cape Town’s Skyline

A tiny, pinsized beetle is slowly killing Cape Town’s trees. This beetle digs into trees and introduces a deadly fungus that chokes the tree from the inside. The city is fighting back with special teams, tree injections, and even citizen help to track the beetle’s spread. They are planning to replace many trees with stronger native species, but it’s a huge, ongoing battle.