AmaBhungane Fights Against “Gagging” Order in Moti Group Case

1 min read
investigative journalism legal battle

Investigative journalism agency AmaBhungane is currently involved in a legal battle against a “gagging” order imposed on them in the Moti Group case. The order, which restricts their reporting on the case, is being contested by AmaBhungane, who argue that it is an example of bullying and a strategic litigation against public participation (SLAPP) suit.

Intimidation of the Media

Advocate Steven Budlender asserts that the Moti Group is attempting to intimidate the media and hinder their ability to do their job. The group, backed by deep pockets, is seeking to silence AmaBhungane by imposing a gag order on their reporting.

Background of the Case

The case began when Judge John Holland-Muter issued an ex parte order instructing AmaBhungane’s journalists to return all leaked documents within 48 hours. These documents served as the basis for their series of articles called “# MotiFiles.” The journalists also faced a gag order preventing them from using these documents to report on the Moti Group until a return date in October.

AmaBhungane brought an urgent application to set aside the order for the documents’ return. The case was then brought before Gauteng Deputy Judge President Roland Sutherland, who heard arguments from both sides.

Allegations Against AmaBhungane

The Moti Group alleges that the documents were stolen by former legal consultant Clinton van Niekerk. They claim that AmaBhungane had become a party to Van Niekerk’s crime since the documents were privileged and confidential. The group argued that journalists had no right to the documents or to report from them.

Judge Sutherland’s Decision

Judge Sutherland dismissed the Moti Group’s attempt to amend the relief it had sought from Judge Holland-Muter through a “counter-application.” The amended application requested that AmaBhungane return the documents to the Moti Group’s lawyers, who would determine what could and could not be reported. Any disputes between the parties would then be adjudicated by a judge.

Advocate Vincent Maleka insisted that this was a compromise that could be considered. However, Judge Sutherland questioned what Judge Holland-Muter had considered when making the ex parte order. He noted the communication between the parties and pointed out that AmaBhungane had provided an undertaking not to destroy the documents.

Budlender’s Argument

Advocate Budlender argued that the Moti Group had not justified their decision to go to court ex parte, calling it a patent abuse. He also pointed out that the Cyber Crime Act had not been featured. Budlender called for the entire order to be dismissed with costs “on the highest scale possible” against the Moti Group.

Submissions from Amicus Curiae

In addition to AmaBhungane’s case, submissions were made by amicus curiae: The South African National Editors Forum, Media Monitoring Africa Trust, Campaign for Free Expression, and Corruption Watch.

Judge Sutherland has reserved judgment and intends to deliver his decision no later than Monday.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Previous Story

The Melodious Charm of the 127th Hollywoodbets Durban July

Next Story

The Unconventional Tribute: Pink’s Encounter with a Fan’s Unique Expression of Devotion

Latest from Blog

Strengthening Ties: South Africa and India’s Strategic Partnership

The partnership between South Africa and India is a powerful bond that goes back to the fight against apartheid. It’s not just about history; both countries share dreams for a better future through advanced technology and strong defense. Deputy Minister Bantu Holomisa highlights the importance of working together, especially to prepare for new challenges like climate change and terrorism. By involving young people and focusing on humanitarian efforts, they are building a brighter, safer tomorrow for everyone. This friendship shows how countries can unite to create peace and growth in a complex world.

A Historic Rugby Showdown in London: Springboks vs. Argentina 2025

Get ready for an unforgettable rugby match in 2025! The Springboks and Argentina will clash at London’s Allianz Stadium in a historic showdown. This is the first time these teams will meet on neutral ground, making the stakes even higher. With passionate fans cheering and a fierce competition on the field, this match could decide the Rugby Championship winner. Both teams are ready to show their skills and make their countries proud in this exciting battle!

Chidimma Adetshina: A Tale of Dreams, Identity, and Controversy

Chidimma Adetshina’s story is a vibrant journey from Nigeria to the glamorous world of beauty pageants. After winning Miss Universe Nigeria, she faced unexpected challenges when she entered Miss South Africa, sparking debates about her citizenship and identity. This controversy brought to light deeper issues surrounding immigration and belonging in Africa. Despite the turmoil, Adetshina returned to Nigeria and continued to chase her dreams, becoming Miss Nigeria 2024, symbolizing resilience and hope amid the chaos. Her tale inspires us to think about what it truly means to belong and pursue our aspirations against all odds.

Nurturing Tomorrow’s Leaders: The Mandela-Sobukwe Leadership Camp

The MandelaSobukwe Leadership Camp in Cape Town is a vibrant annual event that brings together 100 young leaders from across South Africa. Here, students dive into important topics like genderbased violence and mental health, gaining skills and inspiration to spark change in their communities. The camp honors the legacies of Nelson Mandela and Robert Sobukwe, reminding participants of the power of perseverance and courage. As they engage in workshops and share ideas, these young changemakers leave with renewed hope and a toolkit to build a brighter future, embodying the spirit of resilience found in the heart of Cape Town.

The Satirical Asylum: Gasant Abarder’s Middle-Class Musings

Gasant Abarder’s satirical letter humorously asks for asylum from Bangladesh, poking fun at the struggles of middleclass life in South Africa. Using funny stories and sharp observations, he highlights the quirks of identity, the high costs of living, and the absurdities of societal norms. He dreams of cricket glory in Bangladesh while feeling overlooked at home, showing his longing for belonging. Through laughter, Abarder encourages us to reflect on our own lives and seek hope amid chaos, reminding us that humor can help us navigate life’s tricky paths.