PRASA’s Legal Woes

1 min read
prasa legal woes

The Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa (PRASA) has been embroiled in a series of legal battles since early 2021, with the rail agency relying heavily on the services of the law firm De Swardt Myambo Hlahla Attorneys. However, concerns have been raised over PRASA’s procurement practices, with the National Treasury warning that the agency may have violated procurement regulations by using De Swardt, which is not on its legal panel.

The NECSA Panel

PRASA has been advised by the Auditor-General to use the legal panel of the South African Nuclear Energy Corporation (NECSA) since early 2020. However, PRASA claimed that the NECSA panel was “compromised” because it was introduced before the current board was appointed and had been “under the control” of Martha Ngoye, a whistleblower and suspended head of legal at PRASA. PRASA also stated that it did not have sufficient time to verify firms on the NECSA panel.

Request for Deviation

In February 2021, PRASA requested a deviation from normal procurement procedures to allow De Swardt to litigate on behalf of its board in cases against Ngoye, Tiro Holele, and Nkosinathi Khena. However, the National Treasury responded by stating that it was “not verifiable” for PRASA to claim that NECSA’s panel was compromised by Ngoye. The Treasury also stated that any award made to De Swardt must be listed on the e-tender portal, but no such award has been listed.

Continued Use of De Swardt

Despite the National Treasury’s response, De Swardt has continued to provide services to PRASA’s board, not just in the Ngoye, Khena, and Holele matter, but in a growing number of labour-related cases. PRASA’s board, led by Leonard Ramatlakane, issued a resolution authorising De Swardt to represent the rail agency in its challenge to the arbitration award issued to Martha Ngoye in February 2023.

Auditor-General’s Investigation

In October 2022, the Auditor-General began examining R33-million in irregular expenditure by PRASA for the use of law firms not on the agency’s legal panel, including the R17-million paid to De Swardt. PRASA spokesperson Andiswa Makanda declined to comment on the allegations. Five months later, there has been no response from PRASA to questions about De Swardt or the outcome of any investigation into its use.


PRASA’s use of De Swardt has raised concerns over transparency and accountability. The agency’s failure to comply with procurement regulations and use of firms not on its legal panel has resulted in irregular expenditure. The National Treasury’s warning to PRASA highlights the need for greater oversight and adherence to procurement regulations. The investigation by the Auditor-General underscores the importance of transparency and accountability in the use of public funds.

Environmentalist and Outdoor Enthusiast. Amanda is a nature-loving, energetic, and enthusiastic environmentalist who has dedicated her life to exploring and protecting Cape Town's stunning natural landscapes. She is an experienced hiker, wildlife enthusiast, and advocate for sustainable tourism.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Previous Story

The National Sea Rescue Institute (NSRI) Lifeguards: A Glimpse into Their Daily Routine

Next Story

Landmark Conviction: Gang Members Sentenced to 705 Years in Prison

Latest from Blog

A New Dawn for Atlantis Business Hives: Revitalizing Local Commerce

The Atlantis Business Hives has been revitalized, thanks to the city’s efforts to support local traders and provide them with a safe and clean working environment. The upgraded facility offers a wide range of services catering to traders in various sectors, and the city has allocated R184 million for upgrading trading spaces throughout the metro over the next three years. The city is not only focusing on physical infrastructure but also promoting the growth of business skills among traders and emerging entrepreneurs. With the support of the city, the traders of the Atlantis Business Hives are poised to seize fresh opportunities and chart a course towards prosperity and success.

Cape Town Marks 45 Years of Artistic Excellence at the Loeries

Cape Town is celebrating its 45th year of hosting the prestigious Loeries festival, which brings together exceptional talent from Africa and the Middle East for a weeklong immersion into the world of creativity. The festival’s theme, “Blood, Sweat, and Tears,” showcases the resilience and dedication of the brand communications industry. Loeries Creative Week is expected to host approximately 8,000 innovative individuals from over 20 countries, offering an unparalleled opportunity for the exchange of groundbreaking ideas, trends, and best practices. The festival serves as a testament to Cape Town’s dynamic creative community and its commitment to supporting the growth and development of creative industries.

Prompt Action and Remarkable Investigation by SAPS Alexandria Leads to Rapid Conviction

The prompt investigation by the SAPS Alexandria officers led to the recovery of stolen property and the arrest of three accomplices after they apprehended an individual vending suspicious items. As a result, one of the suspects received a sentence of 18 months’ incarceration, suspended for three years, showcasing the outstanding work of the SAPS Alexandria in upholding the law and fostering community collaboration.