Social Housing Company Wins Legal Battle Against Biased Magistrate

1 min read
social housing legal battle

Communicare, a social housing company based in Cape Town, has recently won a legal battle against an allegedly biased acting magistrate who denied an eviction order in favor of the company. The company sought recourse through the Western Cape High Court, citing the Superior Courts Act, which contends that a presiding officer’s bias, malice, or corruption can lead to gross irregularities in proceedings.


The case was initially thought to be a straightforward eviction application. However, the magistrate, Venice Burgins, took a lengthy three hours to read her 68-page order in August of last year. Unbeknownst to Communicare, Burgins had a history of activism against evictions, and specifically against the social housing company itself. She had also run a social media campaign under the name “United Action Group” and was involved in the #CommunicareMustFall movement.

Biased Magistrate Revealed

Shortly after the company’s eviction request was denied, Communicare received an anonymous packet containing documents that led the company to believe that Burgins should have stepped down from the case. These documents revealed that Burgins had published or endorsed numerous hostile opinions about Communicare on social media before considering the eviction request. One example of her rhetoric includes: “The struggle continues, and we SHALL expose the Communicare rot of exploiting our people.” The company also discovered that Burgins had been a member and administrator of the United Action Group since February 2021.

Court Ruling

Judges Ashley Binns-Ward and Nobahle Mangcu-Lockwood concurred that the case should be revisited by a different magistrate. In his judgment, Judge Binns-Ward referenced the global “Bangalore Principles of Judicial Conduct,” which outline the ethical values of impartiality, integrity, and independence that judges should uphold. According to Judge Binns-Ward, judicial officers are duty-bound to refuse cases in which they have a personal stake in the outcome or contested issues. However, Burgins did not oppose the application and failed to clarify the meaning behind her social media activity.

While the case’s merits are not under scrutiny, Judge Binns-Ward acknowledges that parts of the 63-page judgment suggest that personal issues were incorporated into the decision. Initially, Communicare requested a costs order against Burgins, but later withdrew it after she complied with the court’s decision. The company may still bring her misconduct to the attention of the Magistrates Commission if they deem it necessary.

Environmentalist and Outdoor Enthusiast. Amanda is a nature-loving, energetic, and enthusiastic environmentalist who has dedicated her life to exploring and protecting Cape Town's stunning natural landscapes. She is an experienced hiker, wildlife enthusiast, and advocate for sustainable tourism.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Previous Story

A Week of Enforcement and Emergency Services Challenges: Addressing Offences and Speeding

Next Story

Cape Town’s City-Funded Programme Empowers Clothing Industry SMEs and Creates Jobs

Latest from Blog

South Africa’s Stalwart Commitment to Nuclear Energy: The Koeberg Extension Project

South Africa’s commitment to nuclear energy is evident in its Koeberg Extension Project. The project aims to extend the life of the Koeberg nuclear power station by 20 years, ensuring the country’s energy future. Koeberg provides 5% of Eskom’s power generation and is a crucial element in South Africa’s energy ecosystem. The project highlights the country’s technical expertise and dedication to developing domestic talent.

A Look at the Western Cape Government’s Digital Transformation Success

The Western Cape Government has won the Public Service Innovation Award at the United Nations Public Service Forum for its CitizenCentric Digital Transformation project. The project aims to improve the living standards of citizens through the use of digital technology and has been successful in creating a citizenfocused digital infrastructure and eliminating the digital divide. The WCG plans to continue to build on its digital infrastructure to further improve public services.

Unveiling South Africa: A Journey Through Its Incredible Road Trips

Explore the wonders of South Africa through seven incredible road trips, each offering a unique perspective into the nation’s charm and allure. From the Garden Route’s balance of nature and adventure, to the Cape Peninsula’s rugged cliffs and iconic landmarks, to the Midlands Meander’s art, history, and gastronomy, there’s something for everyone. Unmask the cultural and natural splendor of the Wild Coast, indulge in worldclass wine along Route 62, and appreciate the undisturbed coastal scenery of the West Coast Way. South Africa awaits, ready to be uncovered and explored.

“The Shakedown”: A Testament to South African Cinema’s Global Impact

“The Shakedown” is a new South African film set to premiere on Amazon Prime Video on August 8. Directed by Ari Kruger, the film boasts an impressive cast and showcases the talent of the South African film industry. It tells the story of Justin Diamond, a medical aid broker who gets caught up in the criminal underworld of Cape Town, leading to a series of thrilling adventures. With its international distribution, “The Shakedown” is a milestone for South African cinema, showcasing the country’s creativity and narrative prowess.

Building an Inclusive Future: The Presidential Budget Vote of 2024

The Presidential Budget Vote of 2024 outlines President Cyril Ramaphosa’s vision for South Africa’s future, with a focus on inclusive growth, job creation, poverty reduction, and ethical, capable, and developmentoriented governance. The government’s strategy involves collaboration and partnership across the public and private sectors, with civic engagement and scientific innovation playing a key role. The Presidency is committed to tackling youth unemployment, genderbased violence and femicide, and implementing initiatives to improve economic and social wellbeing for all South Africans.