The Bellville Commercial Crimes Court Case: A Multi-Million Rand Fraud Scandal Unveiled

by
1 min read
tender fraud corruption

The Bellville Commercial Crimes Court has recently postponed the case of Paul Matthew Hatting, who faces fraud, corruption, and money laundering charges. The allegations involve a R49 million City of Cape Town tender and provides a glimpse into the murky world of tender fraud and corruption in South Africa.

Hatting’s Role in the Tender Process

Paul Matthew Hatting was a member of the Bid Evaluation Committee (BEC) for the City of Cape Town. He is accused of concealing his conflict of interest to recommend a R49.992 million tender for the supply and delivery of black refuse bags to C’Est Gyms, a close corporation registered with Shu Wei Lu and Irene September as members.

Newsletter

Stay Informed • Cape Town

Get breaking news, events, and local stories delivered to your inbox daily. All the news that matters in under 5 minutes.

Join 10,000+ readers
No spam, unsubscribe anytime

The Involvement of C’Est Gyms

C’Est Gyms has been a service provider for the city since 2006. Although Irene September remained inactive in the company’s operations, Shu Wei Lu managed the daily activities. In addition to C’Est Gyms, three other companies were awarded the tender, which resulted in a payment of R10.4 million to Hatting’s company, where he held sole directorship and signing authority.

Hatting’s Employment History

Hatting has been employed as an administrative officer for supply chain management at C’Est Gyms’ Ndabeni store since March 2002. His roles as a storekeeper and technical advisor provided him with a comprehensive understanding of the City of Cape Town’s service providers.

The Prosecution’s Allegations

The prosecution alleges that Hatting conspired with unknown individuals to manipulate the tender process for refuse bags from C’Est Gyms. In return for his influence, the company would regularly deposit funds into his bank account.

Hatting’s Conflict-of-Interest Declaration

BEC members are required to sign a Conflict-of-Interest Declaration and disclose any conflicts they may have regarding a pending tender. Hatting signed a conflict-of-interest declaration and undertaking of confidentiality in September 2008. However, the prosecution asserts that he misrepresented himself.

Hatting’s Misrepresentations

The prosecution asserts that Hatting amassed over R49 million through these misrepresentations and used the proceeds for personal expenses. They cite 87 transactions valued at over R800,000, 39 cash withdrawals amounting to more than R2.2 million, and payments made to Mercedes Benz and McCarthy Toyota under the name PM Hatting.

Money Laundering

Hatting also transferred funds to companies he had a relationship with, including six transactions totaling R216,000 to Cosmic Gold 532 (a general trading company he purchased from his son’s mother in 2008) and 19 transactions worth over R224,000 to Ttanc Trading. These transactions are considered money laundering.

The case’s postponement to 26 June 2023 allows Hatting time to consult with his legal team. However, it highlights the ongoing challenge of corruption and unscrupulous practices in tender processes in South Africa.

Tags:

You might be interested in

Hannah Kriel is a Cape Town-born journalist who chronicles the city’s evolving food scene—from Bo-Kaap spice routes to Constantia vineyards—for local and international outlets. When she’s not interviewing chefs or tracking the harvest on her grandparents’ Stellenbosch farm, you’ll find her surfing the Atlantic breaks she first rode as a schoolgirl.

View all

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

gang violence community safety
Previous Story

The Menace of Gang-Related Shootings in South Africa

great white sharks shark cage diving
Next Story

A Thrilling Encounter: Debunking the Monster Myth of Great White Sharks

Latest from Blog

Kiteboarding Extreme Sports

Forty Metres of Air: The Morning Kiteboarding Rewrote Physics

Hugo Wigglesworth, a young kiteboarder, defied gravity and rewrote the record books by soaring an incredible 40 meters into the air. He used powerful winds, a perfectly timed jump off a wave, and special gear to achieve this amazing feat. His careful planning and hundreds of practice runs made him fly higher than anyone before, showing the world what’s possible in kiteboarding.

housing crisis Airbnb

Airbnb Under Fire: How Cape Town’s Housing Crunch Became a Tourism Blame-Game

Cape Town’s housing woes are NOT really Airbnb’s fault, even though a viral photo tried to blame them! The real problem is that not enough homes are being built, and lots of new people are moving to the city. Getting building permits takes forever, making homes expensive. Airbnb brings in lots of money and jobs, and even if all Airbnbs disappeared, it wouldn’t fix the big housing shortage. The city needs to build more homes and make it easier to do so, not just point fingers at tourists.

Cape Town Restaurants

Cape Town’s Hottest Tables: Where Summer Tastes Like Salt, Smoke and Midnight Vinyl

Cape Town’s new restaurants are super exciting, offering amazing tastes from the ocean, farms, and even old recipes. Places like Amura serve unique sea dishes, while Tannin has a huge wine list and tiny plates. Café Sofi bakes heavenly pastries, Beach Buns makes awesome burgers, and Le Bistrot de JAN mixes French and South African flavors. These spots let you taste the city’s lively food scene, from fancy dinners to casual beach eats, making every meal an adventure.

South Africa Ocean

Between Concrete and Current – Four Inland Hearts Meet the Indian Ocean

This article tells a beautiful story of four South Africans from inland places who see the Indian Ocean for the very first time. For many, the sea is just a picture, far away and hard to reach. But when these brave people finally touch the salty water, it changes them deeply. They feel the ocean’s power, taste its salt, and understand that this huge, blue world is now a part of their own story, breaking down old ideas about who can connect with the sea.