The Persistence of Corporal Punishment in South African Homes and Schools

2 mins read
corporal punishment south africa

Despite being banned in South Africa for almost 30 years, corporal punishment remains a concerning issue. Recent data from Statistics South Africa (Stats SA) show that 3 out of 10 households in South Africa believe that physically punishing children is acceptable if they talk back or argue with their parents. This revelation came to light during the country’s observation of Child Protection Week.

Households’ Views on Corporal Punishment

Stats SA’s findings indicate that corporal punishment is not only used to discipline children for arguing or talking back, but also for lying and fighting with siblings. A total of 28% of households reportedly agree with the use of physical punishment in these instances.

Corporal Punishment in Schools

The 2021 Children Exposed to Maltreatment report revealed that educators continue to resort to corporal punishment when disciplining students in schools. Shockingly, in 2019, children between the ages of 8 and 11 were the most frequent victims, with 84% of students in this age group experiencing corporal punishment in schools.

Legal Action Against SACE

In light of this alarming scenario, human rights group Section 27 is taking the South African Council of Educators (SACE) to the Supreme Court of Appeal on behalf of the Centre for Child Law (CCL) and two parents. They argue that SACE’s lenient sanctions on corporal punishment need to be reviewed. The case involves two teachers in Gauteng and Limpopo who physically harmed students, causing significant injuries.

In 2015, one teacher struck a Grade 2 student with a PVC pipe, resulting in hospitalization due to an infection. In 2019, the second case involved a Grade 5 student who suffered from bleeding ears and complications after being hit over the head by her teacher. The student had to repeat the year as a result.

SACE’s Sanctions Policy and High Court Ruling

Section 27 pointed out in a statement that these teachers continue to work in classrooms with no consideration for students’ safety and no obligation to correct their behavior. Both teachers received a R15,000 fine, with R5,000 suspended for five years. While SACE declared the teachers would be removed from the educators’ roll, this decision was also suspended for ten years, allowing them to return to their classrooms.

In the High Court, Section 27 requested that SACE revise its Mandatory Sanctions Policy to include rehabilitative and corrective sanctions such as anger management courses. This change would uphold the principle of the best interests of the child and adopt a more child-centered approach, allowing students and their parents to participate in SACE’s disciplinary hearings. Section 27 also requested that the decisions against the two teachers be set aside and reconsidered by SACE.

Although the High Court only agreed to change SACE’s internal policy, Section 27 argued that the organization should have considered the necessity of rehabilitation or retraining for the two teachers to address their violent behavior. In response, SACE is counter-appealing the High Court judgment and challenging the order to revise its Mandatory Sanctions Policy.

Urgent Need for Effective Measures

The ongoing prevalence of corporal punishment in South African households and schools raises questions about the effectiveness of existing policy and calls for further examination of the issue. As the country continues to focus on child protection, the need for implementing effective measures to combat this harmful practice becomes increasingly urgent.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Previous Story

Safety Concerns in Lansdowne: The Aftermath of a Businessman’s Tragic Murder

Next Story

The Art of Italian Coffee Culture Comes Alive at Lello’s Caffè Espresso Bar in Cape Town

Latest from Blog

A Rousing Weekend of Sports in Cape Town

Get ready for an exciting weekend of sports in Cape Town! From rugby to football, the city’s iconic stadiums will be filled with action and adrenaline. The local government fully supports this thrilling atmosphere and encourages residents to rally behind their local teams, fostering a stronger sense of community and camaraderie through sports. Don’t miss out on the exciting games and get your tickets early, as they will not be sold at the stadiums.

The Transformation of Becott Road in Ottery: A Tale of Progress and Community Development

Becott Road in Ottery is getting an infrastructure upgrade that includes replacing over 425 meters of deteriorating water pipes at an estimated cost of R1.7 million. The project is part of the city’s effort to maintain its aging water distribution network and is expected to be completed by May 2024. The opentrench excavation method was selected for this project, and it has created job opportunities for local residents. The project signifies progress, commitment, and resilience of the city.

The Thriving Lower Silvermine Wetland: A Resolute Undertaking for Nature Conservation

The Lower Silvermine Wetland dredging project was a crucial initiative to preserve the ecosystem’s balance, reduce flood hazards, and create a safe breeding environment for threatened species. The project eliminated silt, invasive plants, and reeds overpowering the natural landscape while promoting the growth of native plant species. The LSW serves as a model for other city waterways, providing spaces for leisure activities while ensuring a safe habitat for various wildlife and enhancing overall environmental, physical, and mental health.

The Pursuit of Justice: Limpopo’s Anti-Smuggling Team Strikes Again

The AntiSmuggling team in Limpopo, South Africa, has been commended for their unwavering dedication and diligence. Their recent operation led to the arrest of two men, a stolen vehicle, and a highspeed chase. Led by Lieutenant General Thembi Hadebe, the team’s concentrated efforts during highstakes operations have left a significant impact on law enforcement in the country. Their commitment and resolve serve as a testament to law enforcement agencies worldwide.

The Investec SA Women’s Open: South Africa’s Premier Women’s Golf Event

The Investec SA Women’s Open is South Africa’s premier women’s golf event held in Cape Town. It is a collaboration between the WPGA, the Sunshine Ladies Tour, and the city of Cape Town, promoting the development of female golfers and boosting sports tourism in South Africa. The event boasts significant growth in prize money and international participation, and is broadcasted globally to millions of golf enthusiasts. It is a celebration of women’s golf, a testament to partnerships, and a beacon of growth and advancement in the sport.